The Rorke's Drift VC
(View Discussion Rules)
** IMPORTANT MESSAGE TO ALL USERS **
PLEASE NOTE: This forum is now inactive and is provided for reference purposes only. The live forum is available at www.rorkesdriftvc.com/forum
(Back To Topic List)
|16th January 2004||Ardendorff|
By Steven Etchells
In his book 'The Washing of The Spears' Donald Morris accuses Ardendorff of cowardice,and even claims he wasn't at Rorkes Drift. Yet, Chard's account says differently.Does anyone know why Morris made these claims?
|16th January 2004||John Young|
We have discussed the presence of Lt. Gert W. Adendorff, on the forum at some length. Try a search on Adendorff for some of the past responses.
Frankly, I don't know why Donald Morris made this assumption, but he has influenced other subsequent authors.
I always refer to some contemporary evidence held in the Henry Charles Harford files at the Local History Museum, Durban, KwaZulu-Natal. Harford was tasked with recording the addresses of next-of-kin of members of the Natal Native Contingent. He did so an a small almanac, due to the shortage of paper after Isandlwana. On one of the pages he listed those members of the N.N.C. present at the defence of Rorke's Drift. Included in the list is the name of Lt. Adendorff - that alone was enough given the other evidence to persuade me that Morris' suggestion was unfounded.
Hope that helps.
|19th January 2004||Simon Copley|
Sort of related - I alway find it strange (and an unfortunate continuity weakness in the film) that in "Zulu", Adendorff (played by Gert Van der Bergh, I think) turns up before the battle and advises Chard on tactics etc He is there at the end when the Zulus do the salute BUT you don't see him doing any fighting in between, despite asking Chard where he should be posted ("Choose your own ground" says Chard "It's your country isn't it?") Perhaps Gert chose to hide in the store room? Perhaps the film editors were hedging their bets with regard to history?!!!! (Unlikely!)