Frederick Butler, RN |
Peter Ewart
|
Dawn
I'm sure there must be some discussion boards and forums catering for Royal Naval history in which your queries will be answered - a quick look shows that uboat.com has a forum which seems to include naval history generally. I'm sure there are others and perhaps other contributors here can advise? Frederick Butler appears to have been serving as a quartermaster on HMS Harrier on the night of 7th/8th April 1861, when the UK decennial census was taken. His entry shows him to have been married, and aged 34 years and two months at that date. The commander of the Harrier was Sir Malcolm McGregor, Bt. All the crew are enumerated but I have not established exactly where the vessel was at the time as I have extracted the schedule from Ancestry's online version of the census (it was presumably in British waters, however). I see from a quick google that the Harrier's company suffered some losses in the NZ Wars in 1864. Peter |
||||||||||||
Last edited by Peter Ewart on Sun Jun 03, 2007 9:08 pm; edited 2 times in total |
Peter Ewart
|
Dawn
A further quick look at the online version in 1851 shows a Frederick Butler, son of a William Butler, waterman. Frederick is also described as a waterman, the family residing in Alverstoke, Gosport and FB having been born in Gosport, but the age given is only 16, so it may be someone else - or may be an example of an age given or recorded in the census inaccurately, which was not at all uncommon. Don't know if any of this helps - it is extracted from the census online via Ancestry's subscription site, via a less than perfect index, so it is not impossible, for example, that he actually appears elsewhere in 1851, is mis-indexed, and that the 16 year old is someone else. Gosport will have been full of watermen, after all. Presumably it is his naval career you are keen to pin down? Do you know anything of his later life in civvy street or when he died? Peter |
||||||||||||
|
Dawn
|
Thanks for all that, Peter. It certainly pins down his age at the time of the shipwreck on which had conflicting information. He also seems to have been a midshipman as some stage, in his early twenties, I guess, and there is a photo of him in his middy uniform which I think led people to think he was about 21 at the time of the shipwreck. Just goes to show - crosscheck your references.
I'm afraid Fred must have got a bit fed up with the navy as he deserted the Harrier in Sydney. He was later arrested and was being taken back to the Harrier, then in Manukau Harbour, on the Orpheus. What is significant is that he had taken the bar at that harbour before and so was the only person on the doomed ship who had ever taken that course. However, when he tried to advise the sailing master he was, of course, not believed. He drops from history after giving evidence in the coroners court and a friendly lady at Auckland Maritime Museum says that he deserted again, never to be found. She's not sure exactly when. But that's heresay and I'm trying to find a reliable reference to this. Yes, it is his naval history I am interested in. The Harrier did indeed suffer losses in the Maori wars. What is ironic is that the 2nd lieutenant of the Orpheus, Lt Charles Hill, lost his life a year later in an attack on Gate Pa in Tauranga. He was with the ship HMS Curacoa by then. And thanks once again, Peter, you certainly turned up more information than I ever did using the web. Dawn |
||||||||||||
|
Frederick Butler, RN |
|
||
Powered by phpBB © 2001-2004 phpBB Group
phpBB Style created by phpBBStyles.com and distributed by Styles Database.
phpBB Style created by phpBBStyles.com and distributed by Styles Database.