Wall orientation. |
Alan
Site Admin
|
Martin,
the wall shown on your Facebook site is the North-South wall with the camera at the South end. The wall would therefore be called the East wall when inside the enclosure. The map from Paul Lamberth is accurate with the green arrow pointing north. |
||||||||||||
|
Wall orientation. |
Martin Kidd
|
Thanks Alan,
Call me stupid ( and most people do ) but the direction North shown on maps appears different from others. I refer to Brave Mens Blood page 75. If I stood inside the enclosure and faced north according to the direction shown, it would put the wagon wall behind me in the south. The hospital would be in the west end and the redoubt in the east. I fully accept your explanation but cannot understand that if north actually points more toward the redoubt how the wall can be considered the south wall which the Zulus first attacked. Or indeed how the opposite wall would not be considered the west wall. I question this in good humour and am positive I am missing some point somewhere.. |
||||||||||||
_________________ MAK |
Rusteze
|
The wall that had the two wagons placed in it is the wall that faced South. It faces the Oskarberg from which the initial attack came. It joins the Hospital building in the West and the Commissariat Store in the East. It is made very clear in the sketch plan that accompanies Lt Chard's first report, in which the magnetic North orientation points towards the bottom of the sketch. It should be noted that the later sketch plans by Chard that accompany his report to Queen Victoria reverse that orientation. However, his excellent line drawing of the scene retains the original orientation looking south towards the Oskarberg
Steve |
||||||||||||
_________________ Rusteze |
Alan
Site Admin
|
This is Chard's early map. According to Google Earth, Chard's North is pointing a little more towards westwards,
he does say 'Approx Mag. N' making what is referred to as the south wall, (with the 2 wagons), running more like towards NNE. If it's called the south wall, at least everyone is on the same page. |
||||||||||||
|
Rusteze
|
We are indeed now on the same page! The sketch plan shown is one of three showing different stages of the defence of RD that accompanied the report to Queen Victoria (it is now in the Royal Archives). Chard's original sketch, orientated in the opposite direction, accompanied his earlier official report on the Defence of Rorke's Drift copied to Col. Hassard RE which he wrote on 25 January 1879 and which is now in the National Archives.
Steve |
||||||||||||
_________________ Rusteze |
Wall orientation. |
|
||
Powered by phpBB © 2001-2004 phpBB Group
phpBB Style created by phpBBStyles.com and distributed by Styles Database.
phpBB Style created by phpBBStyles.com and distributed by Styles Database.