![](./templates/Morpheus/images/spacer.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_left_post.gif) | Zulu : The Truth Behind The Film. By Paul Raby | ![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_right_blue.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/ftr_right.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_left_post.gif) | | ![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_right_blue.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/ftr_right.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_left_post.gif) | | ![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_right_blue.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/ftr_right.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_left_post.gif) | | ![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_right_blue.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/ftr_right.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_left_post.gif) | | ![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_right_blue.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/ftr_right.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_left_post.gif) | | ![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_right_blue.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/ftr_right.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_left_post.gif) | | ![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_right_blue.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/ftr_right.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_left_post.gif) | | ![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_right_blue.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/ftr_right.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_left_post.gif) | | ![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_right_blue.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/ftr_right.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_left_post.gif) | | ![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_right_blue.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/ftr_right.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_left_post.gif) | | ![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_right_blue.gif) |
Paul Raby
Joined: 28 Oct 2010 |
Posts: 15 |
Location: York, UK |
|
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/spacer.gif) |
Posted: Fri Feb 10, 2012 1:14 pm |
|
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/posttop_left.gif) |
![Reply with quote Reply with quote](templates/Morpheus/images/lang_english/blue/icon_quote.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/spacer.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/spacer.gif) |
The Scorer wrote: | I read this last week, having bought a copy from "Firing Line" at Cardiff Castle.
It's an interesting book, as I haven't seen the format (script with notes on the accuracy of each scene at regular intervals) used before. I think that it works, though, and it's a useful companion to Sheldon's book.
I was surprised that Sheldon's book doesn't feature in the bibliography, and I do agree that this is a concern.
Another aspect that is a disappointment is that the apparent myth of the drummer boys being killed and mutilated at Isandwhlana is repeated here. Mr Rabey also says that this resulted in future drummer boys being prevented from being on campaigns afterwards. I say "apparent" as I understand from a topic about this subject on the Victorian Wars Forum that this didn't actually happen.
![Smile](images/smiles/icon_smile.gif) |
Glad people are showing interest,Its good to debate. Re. Sheldon,his book is on the making of the film, whereas I feature more on the actual battle. I would love him to read my book. Dr. David Payne at the AZWRS and Dr. Blank at the Military Archive Research Society and not fogetting Dan and Beverley Allen at the Victorian Military Society,all gave it a great review, thes people are experts. To end please note it is Paul Raby and not Rabey.
|
|
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/ftr_right.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_left_post.gif) | | ![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_right_blue.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/ftr_right.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_left_post.gif) | | ![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_right_blue.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/ftr_right.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_left_post.gif) | | ![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_right_blue.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/ftr_right.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_left_post.gif) | | ![](./templates/Morpheus/images/blue/hdr_right_blue.gif) |
Bill Cainan 3
Joined: 19 Feb 2011 |
Posts: 105 |
|
|
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/spacer.gif) |
Posted: Sun Feb 12, 2012 12:03 am |
|
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/posttop_left.gif) |
![Reply with quote Reply with quote](templates/Morpheus/images/lang_english/blue/icon_quote.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/spacer.gif) |
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/spacer.gif) |
Hi Paul
I note that you responded to my comment above with the following:
"Sheldons book was of no use to me,as he deals with the making of the film,whereas I am more interested in the battle."
Yet, the second line of the introduction to your book clearly states: "This book is dedicated to the above film (Zulu) and gives you personal details of the characters and historical facts about the battle, quotes from the defendants and an insight into the making of the film". So perhaps Sheldon's book MIGHT have been of some use to you ? When we spoke on the telephone about the Brecon museum stocking copies of your book, you clearly indicated that you had never heard of Sheldon's book - hence my comment about research.
For those who have not had the opportunity to read your book, it might be useful if I present and overview of it. The book is based around the screenplay of "Zulu", virtually every word spoken being accurately recorded. Comments are then made at regular intervals as to the veracity of what is being portrayed/spoken in the film. Very much a "spot the error" type of approach.
This website has a number of threads where the film's errors have been highlighted, and you would have done well to have gone through the lists first as you only have a smattering of the errors included in your book. For example, you correctly note that the NCOs chevrons are sewn on the wrong arm, but you fail to mention CSgt Bourne is displaying the rank of a LSgt !!!
If, as you say, your interest is more on the battle, then your bibliography list of only seven books seems a bit light - with no primary sources quoted..
My PERSONAL View is that the book is a bit too lightweight on both the film and the battle, and for me, doesn't really do justice to the title "Zulu: The Truth behind the film". On the positive side, the cover is very eyecatching.
Bill
|
|
![](./templates/Morpheus/images/ftr_right.gif) |
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
All times are GMT
Page 1 of 3
|
|
|
| ![](./templates/Morpheus/images/spacer.gif) |